I am a horrible designer. If colour has a version of tone-deaf, that's me, so I need you fine folks to be the real opinion.
My site's got a red, yellow, burnt-orange scheme. I like it and think it fits the story. I also just put up a FavIcon (this little number: (http://theotherkindofroommate.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/04/Tartra_merman.png )), which is teal, blue and blinding yellow. It's supposed to be the brand mascot for my serial's version of Starbucks, so as far as a parody on that goes, I like it and think it fits that brand.
The question I have now is, does this bright blue and teal face fit in with my red and orange site as a fun, unexpected splash of colour, or does it stick out too much because it's not the same red/yellow/orange mix?